McCarthy does explain the controversy, and many details about the hawks in an extensive Author's Note (there is also a separate author's note about Central Park), but her story is really about the excitement and joy of watching nature in the city. Whereas the other books start from the hawk's POV, McCarthy begins with the people, taking us from the noisy, crowded polluted streets, to the lush escape of Central Park. We then watch -- just like birdwatchers -- as the hawks explore the park, make their nest and start a family.
I admit that I am a little in love with the gigantic bug eyes McCarthy gives her characters (human and avian), her illustrations are cheerful and everyone looks to be enjoying themselves. She illustrates various city vistas, and although there are numerous views of the sky, she brings us back down to earth, where we humans live, quite often.
It certainly qualifies as an uplifting tale (no pun intended!).
Want More?
Visit the author's website.
Read all my reviews of Pale Male books.
Visit Central Park.
Gothamist posted a video of Pale Male's new mate.
Big Kid says: You know, lots of other birds also live on rooftops, like sparrows and finches.
Little Kids says: Park book, please.
5 comments:
We watched a Wild Kratts episode about a pair of city hawks in Central Park, but I didn't realize it was a true story - maybe they said that in the intro (which I missed)?
We'll have to look for this book!
Whoa, those are some large eyes!
And, completely unrelated, I thought you'd appreciate this Paper City I ran across this morning. Sadly, sans birds.
http://madebyjoel.com/2010/04/paper-city.html
Illustrations do look rather more engaging in this book. What is your personal favorite of Pale Male's stories?
I have teh same question - which is your favorite? If you had to pick just one, which would you pick?
So challenging to pick only one! For younger kids I would pick City Hawk, but for older kids I would choose Pale Male: Citizen Hawk of New York City. There is a lot more text and information in Pale Male: Citizen... not many 3 or 4 year olds would want to sit through it.
Post a Comment